MEPR wrote:
the toyotas have an 8" ring gear where as the dana 44 has either a 8" ring gear pre 80 or a 8.5" ring gear post 80. The benefit of the Toy axels is that they are third member axles. So when alot of stress is applied to the pinion it wont climb up the ring gear and strip teeth. Thats wht the ford 9" is such a great axel. I also would go for the Toyota stuff, honestly its stronger than Isuzu stuff. As far as motor, i would probly still run a 22re, LC Engineering sells HOT 22rs and REs

all d44s have an 8.5" ring gear, but the strength between that and a toyota R&P is pretty minimal. LC is a good place for toy engine parts, but building a nice little 22R mill isn't hard at all and can be done cheaper than any run of the mill chevy 350(beat $215 for a master kit with pistons, rings, bearings etc).
as far as the third member thing, that only means that the section with the gears drops out of the axle housing as opposed to a dana style axle. however toyotas and the 9" are similar in the fact that they have an adjustable carrier bearing preload and backlash, but the 9" has a 3rd bearing on the end of the pinion gear. the reason the 9" is so popular is that it's cheap, axles are everywhere, and the pinion gear is HUGE!
there's a high pinion 3rd member available for toyota axles(its actually the factory 3rd from a front axle of a 90s land cruiser) which is good for strength in the front end(gears run on the "drive" side while going forward) and ground clearance
i wasn't aware the isuzu 12 bolt had disk brakes, but that's cool. i think i'd rather hunt for one of their d44s from an amigo though, as i've seen the price of gearsets for isuzu axles

toy rear ends can be converted to disks though...