800xl wrote:
The only other thing I can think of it that you missed a bolt somewhere on it. Its not hard to miss one it you still have it in the truck.
I would agree with this part, when I last pulled mine I missed I think it was 3 bolts on the bottom of the transmission, they were smaller than the rest of the bolts. There was so much grease and dirt caked on my transmission I couldn't feel them, but I had much the same symptoms you are describing.
Take your time and just be sure to double and tripple check to make sure there aren't any more bolts and if all else fails, like 800 said, pull em both together.
Chad