That sucks to keep getting BAD parts over and over. I had a 1970 Datsun pickup when I was a teenager and had massive electrical problems with it. I had almost no mechanical experience then and couldn't afford to take it to a mechanic so I Toggle switch and hot wired everything. I had to install an electric fuel pump then put it on a toggle switch, (had to remember to turn it off when I shut the truck off), had intermittent ignition probems that would keep it from starting that I could never track down so I put in a Hot wire push button completing a circuit from the coil to the battery so it would start and once started it would run. (my dad helped with that, still not exactly sure how we did it) Gages didn't always work though. Then all of a sudden, it would start and run like normal for a while. Windshield wipers were also on a toggle switch, high speed only. Hey, the heater worked on it's own switch though.
Hearing you say you had your fuel pump on a toggle switch reminded me of all that. Good luck with the fix.